How to Evaluate a Website: Comprehensive Usability and Accessibility Guide

osbay devRemote Engineer Dispatch
A modern, inclusive digital workspace where a diverse team evaluates a website’s accessibility and usability on multiple screens. In the center, a large, sleek computer monitor displays a clean, modern website layout with clear sections, buttons, and images, surrounded by subtle UI elements like sliders, forms, and navigation menus. Around the main screen, several smaller floating panels show key evaluation aspects: a color contrast checker with contrasting color swatches, a keyboard icon with arrow keys highlighting keyboard navigation, a screen reader waveform or audio icon, a checklist with WCAG-like checkmarks, and simple metrics/analytics graphs. In the foreground, three to four people of different ages, genders, and ethnicities collaborate: one using a laptop with a keyboard focus outline on the screen, another using a tablet with zoomed-in content, another wearing small over-ear headphones representing screen reader usage, and one person in a wheelchair participating equally at the table. Their body language shows focused, thoughtful collaboration, not stress. The environment is a bright, modern office with a large desk, plants, and minimal decor, symbolizing clarity and professionalism. The overall mood is analytical yet optimistic and empowering, emphasizing improving websites for everyone. Use a semi-isometric or slightly elevated wide shot to capture screens, people, and floating UI panels in one cohesive composition. Art style: clean, polished, high-end digital illustration with mild isometric/flat design influences; crisp lines, subtle gradients, no text. Color palette: cool and professional with blues, teals, and soft neutrals, accented by a few warm highlights (oranges/yellows) for key UI elements and icons. Lighting: soft, bright, and even, with gentle glow around the main monitor and floating panels to draw focus, conveying clarity, modern technology, and accessibility-first design.

how to evaluate a website comprehensive usability and accessibility guide

How to Evaluate a Website: Comprehensive Usability and Accessibility Guide

If you’ve ever clicked on a website and instantly felt lost, you already know why website evaluation matters. A website can look beautiful and still be confusing, frustrating, or even impossible to use for some people.

In this guide, we’ll walk through how to evaluate a website step by step, focusing on both usability and accessibility. Think of it as a simple checklist you can use whether you’re a business owner, designer, developer, or just curious about what makes a great site.

—

Why Evaluating a Website Matters

A website is often the first place people meet your brand. If that experience is slow, confusing, or inaccessible, many visitors will leave and never come back.

A strong website should be:

  • Easy to navigate – People can find what they need quickly.
  • Clear and readable – Content is simple, scannable, and helpful.
  • Accessible – People of all abilities can use it, including those using assistive technologies.
  • Fast and secure – Pages load quickly and protect user data.

If you’re thinking, “That sounds like a lot,” don’t worry. We’ll break it down into manageable areas you can review one by one.

—

1. Start With First Impressions

When you land on a website, the first 5–10 seconds tell you a lot. Ask yourself:

  • Do I instantly understand what this site is about?
  • Can I see the main action the site wants me to take (sign up, buy, learn more)?
  • Is the layout clean, or does it feel cluttered and overwhelming?

A good website has a clear visual hierarchy. This simply means important elements stand out more than less important ones. For example:

  • Headlines are larger than body text.
  • Buttons use clear colors that contrast with the background.
  • Key actions (like “Contact Us” or “Get Started”) are easy to spot.

If you have to hunt around to figure out what the site does, that’s a red flag.

—

2. Check Navigation and Structure

Next, look at how the website is organized. A useful analogy: imagine the website is a store. Can visitors find the “aisles” they need?

Here’s what to evaluate:

Clear Menu and Labels

  • Is the main menu easy to see at the top or side of the page?
  • Are menu labels simple and descriptive (like “Pricing,” “Services,” “Blog”) instead of vague terms?
  • Does the logo link back to the homepage?

If users cannot predict where a link will go based on its label, the navigation isn’t doing its job.

Logical Page Structure

Click through a few pages. Does the layout feel consistent?

  • Are similar elements (like forms, buttons, and headings) in familiar positions?
  • Is there a breadcrumb trail (e.g., Home > Services > Web Design) on complex sites?

A clear structure reduces cognitive load and makes the site more usable for everyone.

—

3. Evaluate Content and Readability

Even a stunning design fails if the content is confusing. Look closely at the text on each page.

Plain, Simple Language

Ask:

  • Is the content written in everyday language?
  • Are long paragraphs broken up into shorter ones?
  • Are there headings and subheadings to help scan the page?

Web users often skim before they commit to reading. Using short sentences, bullet points, and clear headings can help them quickly find what they need.

Readable Typography

Check:

  • Is the font size large enough to read comfortably, even on smaller screens?
  • Is there enough spacing between lines and paragraphs?
  • Is there strong contrast between text and background?

If you find yourself squinting or highlighting text to focus, the typography may need improvement.

—

4. Test Website Accessibility

Accessibility is about making sure everyone can use your website, including people with disabilities. This isn’t just “nice to have”—in many countries, it’s required by law.

Here are key areas to review:

Keyboard Navigation

Try using your keyboard only:

  • Can you move through links and buttons with the Tab key?
  • Is there a visible focus outline showing where you are on the page?
  • Can you use forms and menus without a mouse?

If you can’t complete basic tasks using only your keyboard, users who rely on assistive devices will struggle too.

Alt Text for Images

Images should have alt text (alternative text) that describes the image for people using screen readers.

Ask:

  • Do important images (like buttons, icons, or infographics) have meaningful descriptions?
  • Is decorative imagery marked so it’s skipped, rather than read out loud?

Good alt text gives context, not just labels. For example, “Woman using a laptop in a home office” is more helpful than “image1.”

Color and Contrast

People with low vision or color blindness may have trouble with low-contrast designs.

Check:

  • Do text and backgrounds have strong contrast?
  • Is color ever the only way information is conveyed (like “click the red button”)?

There are free online tools that check contrast ratios and show if they meet accessibility guidelines.

Headings and Structure for Screen Readers

Headings (

,

,

, etc.) are more than just styling—they help screen readers understand page structure.

Look for:

  • A single, clear H1 heading that describes the page.
  • Logical heading levels in order, without skipping around.

If headings are used only for visual effects, users relying on assistive tech may have a hard time navigating.

—

5. Review Performance and Mobile Experience

We’ve all closed a slow-loading page. Speed is a huge part of both usability and SEO.

Page Speed

Ask:

  • Do pages load within a few seconds?
  • Are large images or videos slowing things down?

You can use tools like Google PageSpeed Insights to see what’s causing delays and get suggestions to improve performance.

Mobile Responsiveness

Most visitors today browse from their phones. Visit the website on a mobile device and check:

  • Does the layout adjust without forcing you to pinch and zoom?
  • Are buttons large enough to tap easily?
  • Is text still readable on a small screen?

If the mobile version feels like an afterthought, users are likely to bounce.

—

6. Look at Forms and Interactive Elements

Forms are often where visitors turn into leads or customers—contact forms, sign-ups, checkouts, and more. That makes them critical to evaluate.

  • Are form fields clearly labeled?
  • Is it obvious which fields are required?
  • Do you see helpful error messages if you make a mistake?
  • Can you complete forms using only the keyboard?

A good test is to pretend you’re in a hurry. Can you complete the form quickly and confidently? If not, your real users will likely feel the same.

—

7. Don’t Forget Trust and Credibility

People won’t stay on a website they don’t trust. Look for:

  • Clear contact information (email, phone, or address).
  • Privacy policy and terms of use links.
  • Secure connection (the URL should start with https://).
  • Testimonials, case studies, or social proof, when relevant.

Small trust signals go a long way in making visitors feel safe and comfortable.

—

Putting It All Together: A Simple Website Evaluation Checklist

To recap, when you evaluate a website for usability and accessibility, work through these key areas:

  • First impressions and clarity of purpose
  • Navigation and overall structure
  • Content quality and readability
  • Accessibility (keyboard use, alt text, contrast, headings)
  • Performance and mobile responsiveness
  • Forms and interactive elements
  • Trust, security, and credibility

You don’t need to be a designer or developer to spot many of these issues. Often, a bit of honest testing—by you, your team, or real users—can reveal what’s working and what needs improvement.

—

Final Thoughts

Evaluating a website isn’t a one-time job. As your content, users, and technology change, your site should evolve too.

If you regularly review usability and accessibility, you’ll build a website that’s not only more inclusive, but also more effective at reaching your goals. After all, a truly great website doesn’t just look good—it works well for everyone who visits it.